共查询到20条相似文献，搜索用时 62 毫秒
1.
Preequating is in demand because it reduces score reporting time. In this article, we evaluated an observed‐score preequating method: the empirical item characteristic curve (EICC) method, which makes preequating without item response theory (IRT) possible. EICC preequating results were compared with a criterion equating and with IRT true‐score preequating conversions. Results suggested that the EICC preequating method worked well under the conditions considered in this study. The difference between the EICC preequating conversion and the criterion equating was smaller than .5 raw‐score points (a practical criterion often used to evaluate equating quality) between the 5th and 95th percentiles of the new form total score distribution. EICC preequating also performed similarly or slightly better than IRT true‐score preequating. 相似文献
2.
Test equating might be affected by including in the equating analyses examinees who have taken the test previously. This study evaluated the effect of including such repeaters on Medical College Admission Test (MCAT) equating using a population invariance approach. Three-parameter logistic (3-PL) item response theory (IRT) true score and traditional equipercentile equating methods were used under the random groups equating design. This study also examined whether or not population sensitivity of equating by repeater status varies depending on other background variables (gender and ethnicity). The results indicated that there was some evidence of repeaters' effect on equating with varying amounts of such effect by gender. 相似文献
3.
《教育实用测度》2013,26(4):383-407
The performance of the item response theory (IRT) true-score equating method is examined under conditions of test multidimensionality. It is argued that a primary concern in applying unidimensional equating methods when multidimensionality is present is the potential decrease in equity (Lord, 1980) attributable to the fact that examinees of different ability are expected to obtain the same test scores. In contrast to equating studies based on real test data, the use of simulation in equating research not only permits assessment of these effects but also enables investigation of hypothetical equating conditions in which multidimensionality can be suspected to be especially problematic for test equating. In this article, I investigate whether the IRT true-score equating method, which explicitly assumes the item response matrix is unidimensional, is more adversely affected by the presence of multidimensionality than 2 conventional equating methods-linear and equipercentile equating-using several recently proposed equity-based criteria (Thomasson, 1993). Results from 2 simulation studies suggest that the IRT method performs at least as well as the conventional methods when the correlation between dimensions is high (³ 0.7) and may be only slightly inferior to the equipercentile method when the correlation is moderate to low (£ 0.5). 相似文献
4.
Bjrn Andersson 《Journal of Educational Measurement》2016,53(4):459-477
In observed‐score equipercentile equating, the goal is to make scores on two scales or tests measuring the same construct comparable by matching the percentiles of the respective score distributions. If the tests consist of different items with multiple categories for each item, a suitable model for the responses is a polytomous item response theory (IRT) model. The parameters from such a model can be utilized to derive the score probabilities for the tests and these score probabilities may then be used in observed‐score equating. In this study, the asymptotic standard errors of observed‐score equating using score probability vectors from polytomous IRT models are derived using the delta method. The results are applied to the equivalent groups design and the nonequivalent groups design with either chain equating or poststratification equating within the framework of kernel equating. The derivations are presented in a general form and specific formulas for the graded response model and the generalized partial credit model are provided. The asymptotic standard errors are accurate under several simulation conditions relating to sample size, distributional misspecification and, for the nonequivalent groups design, anchor test length. 相似文献
5.
Haiwen Chen 《Journal of Educational Measurement》2012,49(3):269-284
In this article, linear item response theory (IRT) observed‐score equating is compared under a generalized kernel equating framework with Levine observed‐score equating for nonequivalent groups with anchor test design. Interestingly, these two equating methods are closely related despite being based on different methodologies. Specifically, when using data from IRT models, linear IRT observed‐score equating is virtually identical to Levine observed‐score equating. This leads to the conclusion that poststratification equating based on true anchor scores can be viewed as the curvilinear Levine observed‐score equating. 相似文献
6.
Various applications of item response theory often require linking to achieve a common scale for item parameter estimates obtained from different groups. This article used a simulation to examine the relative performance of four different item response theory (IRT) linking procedures in a random groups equating design: concurrent calibration with multiple groups, separate calibration with the Stocking-Lord method, separate calibration with the Haebara method, and proficiency transformation. The simulation conditions used in this article included three sampling designs, two levels of sample size, and two levels of the number of items. In general, the separate calibration procedures performed better than the concurrent calibration and proficiency transformation procedures, even though some inconsistent results were observed across different simulation conditions. Some advantages and disadvantages of the linking procedures are discussed. 相似文献
7.
Accurate equating results are essential when comparing examinee scores across exam forms. Previous research indicates that equating results may not be accurate when group differences are large. This study compared the equating results of frequency estimation, chained equipercentile, item response theory (IRT) true‐score, and IRT observed‐score equating methods. Using mixed‐format test data, equating results were evaluated for group differences ranging from 0 to .75 standard deviations. As group differences increased, equating results became increasingly biased and dissimilar across equating methods. Results suggest that the size of group differences, the likelihood that equating assumptions are violated, and the equating error associated with an equating method should be taken into consideration when choosing an equating method. 相似文献
8.
This study investigates a sequence of item response theory (IRT) true score equatings based on various scale transformation approaches and evaluates equating accuracy and consistency over time. The results show that the biases and sample variances for the IRT true score equating (both direct and indirect) are quite small (except for the mean/sigma method). The biases and sample variances for the equating functions based on the characteristic curve methods and concurrent calibrations for adjacent forms are smaller than the biases and variances for the equating functions based on the moment methods. In addition, the IRT true score equating is also compared to the chained equipercentile equating, and we observe that the sample variances for the chained equipercentile equating are much smaller than the variances for the IRT true score equating with an exception at the low scores. 相似文献
9.
Jenna Copella 《教育实用测度》2013,26(1):73-76
Combinations of five methods of equating test forms and two methods of selecting samples of students for equating were compared for accuracy. The two sampling methods were representative sampling from the population and matching samples on the anchor test score. The equating methods were the Tucker, Levine equally reliable, chained equipercentile, frequency estimation, and item response theory (IRT) 3PL methods. The tests were the Verbal and Mathematical sections of the Scholastic Aptitude Test. The criteria for accuracy were measures of agreement with an equivalent-groups equating based on more than 115,000 students taking each form. Much of the inaccuracy in the equatings could be attributed to overall bias. The results for all equating methods in the matched samples were similar to those for the Tucker and frequency estimation methods in the representative samples; these equatings made too small an adjustment for the difference in the difficulty of the test forms. In the representative samples, the chained equipercentile method showed a much smaller bias. The IRT (3PL) and Levine methods tended to agree with each other and were inconsistent in the direction of their bias. 相似文献
10.
ABSTRACTCurrent procedures for equating number-correct scores using traditional item response theory (IRT) methods assume local independence. However, when tests are constructed using testlets, one concern is the violation of the local item independence assumption. The testlet response theory (TRT) model is one way to accommodate local item dependence. This study proposes methods to extend IRT true score and observed score equating methods to the dichotomous TRT model. We also examine the impact of local item dependence on equating number-correct scores when a traditional IRT model is applied. Results of the study indicate that when local item dependence is at a low level, using the three-parameter logistic model does not substantially affect number-correct equating. However, when local item dependence is at a moderate or high level, using the three-parameter logistic model generates larger equating bias and standard errors of equating compared to the TRT model. However, observed score equating is more robust to the violation of the local item independence assumption than is true score equating. 相似文献
11.
The present study evaluated the multiple imputation method, a procedure that is similar to the one suggested by Li and Lissitz (2004), and compared the performance of this method with that of the bootstrap method and the delta method in obtaining the standard errors for the estimates of the parameter scale transformation coefficients in item response theory (IRT) equating in the context of the common‐item nonequivalent groups design. Two different estimation procedures for the variance‐covariance matrix of the IRT item parameter estimates, which were used in both the delta method and the multiple imputation method, were considered: empirical cross‐product (XPD) and supplemented expectation maximization (SEM). The results of the analyses with simulated and real data indicate that the multiple imputation method generally produced very similar results to the bootstrap method and the delta method in most of the conditions. The differences between the estimated standard errors obtained by the methods using the XPD matrices and the SEM matrices were very small when the sample size was reasonably large. When the sample size was small, the methods using the XPD matrices appeared to yield slight upward bias for the standard errors of the IRT parameter scale transformation coefficients. 相似文献
12.
Item response theory (IRT) methods are generally used to create score scales for large-scale tests. Research has shown that IRT scales are stable across groups and over time. Most studies have focused on items that are dichotomously scored. Now Rasch and other IRT models are used to create scales for tests that include polytomously scored items. When tests are equated across forms, researchers check for the stability of common items before including them in equating procedures. Stability is usually examined in relation to polytomous items' central “location” on the scale without taking into account the stability of the different item scores (step difficulties). We examined the stability of score scales over a 3–5-year period, considering both stability of location values and stability of step difficulties for common item equating. We also investigated possible changes in the scale measured by the tests and systematic scale drift that might not be evident in year-to-year equating. Results across grades and content areas suggest that equating results are comparable whether or not the stability of step difficulties is taken into account. Results also suggest that there may be systematic scale drift that is not visible using year-to-year common item equating. 相似文献
13.
《International Journal of Educational Research》1988,12(4):409-425
Six equating methods were compared: a one-parameter Item Response Theory (IRT) method; two equipercentile methods (direct and by frequency estimation); and three linear methods (Tucker, Levine Equally Reliable and Levine Unequally Reliable) in a situation in which different forms were administered to different groups, thus necessitating the use of an anchor test. The groups were simulated as either equivalent groups or groups of variable ability representing the two types of class groupings that can exist in schools (i.e. parallel or streamed classes). The correlation between the ability measured by an external anchor and the tests to be equated was systematically manipulated. A discrepancy index summarised the discrepancy of each equating method from an IRT criterion, an equipercentile criterion, and from each other. Large discrepancies were interpreted with the aid of graphs and discussed in terms of examinee indifference to the alternative transformations. The direct equipercentile and Levine Unequally Reliable methods were the only methods that consistently increased their level of the discrepancy from criterion following reduction in correlation for the two equatings examined in the equivalent groups design. For the non-equivalent groups design, a reduction in correlation resulted in a systematic effect in favour of those taking an easier form (usually the less able) for all equating methods. What was observed, however, was that for small reductions in correlation, the discrepancy of some of the equating methods from the IRT criterion was reduced. The implications of these findings are discussed and recommendations made for further work. 相似文献
14.
Five methods for equating in a random groups design were investigated in a series of resampling studies with samples of 400, 200, 100, and 50 test takers. Six operational test forms, each taken by 9,000 or more test takers, were used as item pools to construct pairs of forms to be equated. The criterion equating was the direct equipercentile equating in the group of all test takers. Equating accuracy was indicated by the root-mean-squared deviation, over 1,000 replications, of the sample equatings from the criterion equating. The methods investigated were equipercentile equating of smoothed distributions, linear equating, mean equating, symmetric circle-arc equating, and simplified circle-arc equating. The circle-arc methods produced the most accurate results for all sample sizes investigated, particularly in the upper half of the score distribution. The difference in equating accuracy between the two circle-arc methods was negligible. 相似文献
15.
In operational testing programs using item response theory (IRT), item parameter invariance is threatened when an item appears in a different location on the live test than it did when it was field tested. This study utilizes data from a large state's assessments to model change in Rasch item difficulty (RID) as a function of item position change, test level, test content, and item format. As a follow-up to the real data analysis, a simulation study was performed to assess the effect of item position change on equating. Results from this study indicate that item position change significantly affects change in RID. In addition, although the test construction procedures used in the investigated state seem to somewhat mitigate the impact of item position change, equating results might be impacted in testing programs where other test construction practices or equating methods are utilized. 相似文献
16.
The equating performance of two internal anchor test structures—miditests and minitests—is studied for four IRT equating methods using simulated data. Originally proposed by Sinharay and Holland, miditests are anchors that have the same mean difficulty as the overall test but less variance in item difficulties. Four popular IRT equating methods were tested, and both the means and SDs of the true ability of the group to be equated were varied. We evaluate equating accuracy marginally and conditional on true ability. Our results suggest miditests perform about as well as traditional minitests for most conditions. Findings are discussed in terms of comparability to the typical minitest design and the trade‐off between accuracy and flexibility in test construction. 相似文献
17.
《教育实用测度》2013,26(2):125-141
Item parameter instability can threaten the validity of inferences about changes in student achievement when using Item Response Theory- (IRT) based test scores obtained on different occasions. This article illustrates a model-testing approach for evaluating the stability of IRT item parameter estimates in a pretest-posttest design. Stability of item parameter estimates was assessed for a random sample of pretest and posttest responses to a 19-item math test. Using MULTILOG (Thissen, 1986), IRT models were estimated in which item parameter estimates were constrained to be equal across samples (reflecting stability) and item parameter estimates were free to vary across samples (reflecting instability). These competing models were then compared statistically in order to test the invariance assumption. The results indicated a moderately high degree of stability in the item parameter estimates for a group of children assessed on two different occasions. 相似文献
18.
The current study proposed several variants of simple-structure multidimensional item response theory equating procedures. Four distinct sets of data were used to demonstrate feasibility of proposed equating methods for two different equating designs: a random groups design and a common-item nonequivalent groups design. Findings indicated some notable differences between the multidimensional and unidimensional approaches when data exhibited evidence for multidimensionality. In addition, some of the proposed methods were successful in providing equating results for both section-level and composite-level scores, which has not been achieved by most of the existing methodologies. The traditional method of using a set of quadrature points and weights for equating turned out to be computationally intensive, particularly for the data with higher dimensions. The study suggested an alternative way of using the Monte-Carlo approach for such data. This study also proposed a simple-structure true-score equating procedure that does not rely on a multivariate observed-score distribution. 相似文献
19.
IRT Equating Methods 总被引：1，自引：0，他引：1
The purpose of this instructional module is to provide the basis for understanding the process of score equating through the use of item response theory (IRT). A context is provided for addressing the merits of IRT equating methods. The mechanics of IRT equating and the need to place parameter estimates from separate calibration runs on the same scale are discussed. Some procedures for placing parameter estimates on a common scale are presented. In addition, IRT true-score equating is discussed in some detail. A discussion of the practical advantages derived from IRT equating is offered at the end of the module. 相似文献