| 《〈资治通鉴〉标点纠谬》一文献疑——兼以实例看《资治通鉴》择取史料的严谨性 |
| |
| 引用本文： | 段锐超.《〈资治通鉴〉标点纠谬》一文献疑——兼以实例看《资治通鉴》择取史料的严谨性[J].洛阳师范学院学报,2014(12):59-61. |
| |
| 作者姓名： | 段锐超 |
| |
| 作者单位： | 陕西理工学院 图书馆,陕西 汉中,723001 |
| |
| 摘 要： | 王友敏先生《〈资治通鉴〉标点纠谬》提出,《北史》《北齐书》及《资治通鉴》中的"薛孤康买"应断为"薛孤康、买",指"薛孤康、薛孤买"二人;"薛孤延康买"应为"薛孤延、康、买",指"薛孤延、薛孤康、薛孤买"三人。王先生的主要依据是《元和姓纂》的一则史料,因其论证欠严密,且以其结论比照于历史情境也存在诸多不合,故其结论恐难成立。按当时的出使惯例,"薛孤康买"作为使主,只能是姓薛孤名康买之一人,《资治通鉴》对此已有鉴别与修正之功;"薛孤延康买"当为二人,但究竟是"薛孤延、康买"还是"薛孤延、薛孤康买"尚难确论。
|
| 关 键 词： | 薛孤 康买 薛孤康买 薛孤延 《资治通鉴》 《北史》 《北齐书》 |
Doubts about Correction of Punctuations in Comprehensive Mirror for Aid in Government---And discussing the conscientiousness in selecting historical materials in Comprehensive Mirror for Aid in Government |
| |
| DUAN Rui-chao.Doubts about Correction of Punctuations in Comprehensive Mirror for Aid in Government---And discussing the conscientiousness in selecting historical materials in Comprehensive Mirror for Aid in Government[J].Journal of Luoyang Teachers College,2014(12):59-61. |
| |
| Authors: | DUAN Rui-chao |
| |
| Institution: | DUAN Rui-chao (Library, Shaanxi University of Technology, Hanzhong 723000, China) |
| |
| Abstract: | Mr.Wang Youmin proposed a new viewpoint according to the historical materials in Yuanhexing-zuan（《元和姓纂》） mainly in his paper Correction of Punctuations in Comprehensive Mirror for Aid in Government. He thought that“Xuegukangmai” in Beishi, Beiqishu and Comprehensive Mirror for Aid in Government referred to“Xuegu Kang” and“Xuegu Mai” and that“Xueguyankangmai” referred to “XueguYan, Xuegu Kang and Xuegu Mai”.In my opinion, Mr Wang’ argument is not rigorous, which does not conform to the historical situation.Ac-cording to the usual practice in sending envoys, “Xuegukangmai” should be one person whose name is “Xuegu Kangmai” as ambassador.Comprehensive Mirror for Aid in Government differentiated and corrected this, which we should pay attention to.According to the historical records,“Xueguyankangmai” should refer to two persons.But we cannot be sure whether it refers to“ Xue Guyan and Kangmai” or“Xue Guyan and Xuegu Kangmai”. |
| |
| Keywords: | Xuegu Kangmai Xuegu Kangmai Xue Guyan Comprehensive Mirror for Aid in Government (《资治通鉴》) Beishi(《北史》) Beiqishu(《北齐书》) |
| 本文献已被 CNKI 维普 等数据库收录！ |
|
